Tagset Queries - Post 2

[chocolateboxmod]

We're back with more tagset queries!

• Marvel and DC Comics - at 7 votes versus 5, the winner is merged tags (one for Marvel Comics, one for DC). You will have 24 hours to put disambiguations onto them if you want specific titles otherwise we'll merge them without specific disambiguation.
• Agent Carter - Steve Rogers does not appear in this show, please move these nominations to Crossover Fandom
• DC's Arrowverse - there are nominations for Clark Kent (Superman Returns (2006)) in here. Is that a crossover or part of the Arrowverse now?
• Fantastic Four - Tony Stark does not appear in this movie, please move these nominations to Crossover Fandom.
• Rogue One - Luke Skywalker and Poe Dameron do not appear in this movie, please move these nominations to Crossover Fandom.
• Star Wars Prequel Trilogy - Ahsoka Tano does not appear in these movies, please move to Crossover Fandom.
• Star Wars Sequel Trilogy - Kes Dameron does not appear in these movies, please move to Crossover Fandom.
• Chronicles of Narnia - AMT - please pick a version.
• No Fandom - please move these nominations to Crossover Fandom
• Supergirl - is this part of the Arrowverse?
• Persona Series - please move to Crossover Fandom and/or Persona 3.
• The Witcher AMT - please pick a version
• Terminator movies - do you want these separate or merged together?
• The Hobbit - AMT - please pick a version.
• Injustice: Gods Among Us - is this the video game or comic book run?
• Star Trek novels - do you want these all merged into "Star Trek - Various Authors"?
• TOLKIEN J. R. R. - Works & Related Fandoms - please choose a more specific fandom.

Any duplicates, missing fandoms, duplicated fandoms, let us know!

Comments

[klutzygirl]

2006 Superman Returns Clark is now part of the Arrowverse - he had a major role in the latest crossover.

And yes, Supergirl is in the Arrowverse!

[sadlikeknives]

Some duplicate tags I noticed:

In "Kate Daniels - Ilona Andrews" there are three:
"Barabas Gilliam/Christopher Steed (Kate Daniels - Ilona Andrews)" and "Barabas Gilliam/Christopher Steed (Kate Daniels)"
"Hugh d'Ambray & Julie Olsen (Kate Daniels - Ilona Andrews)" and "Hugh d'Ambray & Julie Olsen (Kate Daniels)"
"Kate Daniels & Hugh d'Ambray & Erra (Kate Daniels - Ilona Andrews)" and "Hugh d'Ambray & Kate Daniels & Erra (Kate Daniels)"

In "Hidden Legacy Series - Ilona Andrews":
"Augustine Montgomery/Connor Rogan (Hidden Legacy Series - Ilona Andrews)" and "Augustine Montgomery/Connor Rogan (Hidden Legacy)"

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be fixed up now!

[(Anonymous)]

-Injustice: Gods Among Us - is this the video game or comic book run?

Are you asking for the nominator? Or in general? The comic book run (that serves as a prequel to the video game) was written by Tom Taylor if that helps. NetherRealm Studios did the video game with the same name. If it helps any with your decision if the nom doesn’t get back with you.

~Kameiko

PS: awesome about the merged tags! Thanks for that :D

[chocolateboxmod]

Last year we accepted the tag as-is and then were queried after the fact as to which version it was. We'd like to know before we approve the tag this year what one they mean.

[narya_flame]

Celebrimbor/Sauron (Silmarillion) has gone for a walk into The Hobbit and LOTR book tag sets. It's also in the Silmarillion tagset twice, as Celebrimbor/Sauron and Annatar/Celebrimbor (Annatar is an alias of Sauron).

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[crookedspoon]

Injustice: Gods Among Us
Basically the whole universe, both games + tie-in comics.

Re: merged tags
Does that mean comics apart from the main continuity like batman: white Knight would fall under dc comics?

[chocolateboxmod]

Thank you for that! And yes, that's right regarding comics.

[rubylily]

There are a few duplicates under Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magika | Puella Magi Madoka Magica:

Akemi Homura/Kaname Madoka (Madoka Magica) & Akemi Homura/Kaname Madoka (PMMM)

Miki Sayaka/Sakura Kyouko (Madoka Magica) & Miki Sayaka/Sakura Kyouko (PMMM)

Sakura Kyouko/Tomoe Mami (PMMM) & Tomoe Mami/Sakura Kyouko (Madoka Magica)

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be fixed up now!

[wolf_of_lilacs]

Duplicates:
Under Star Wars Original Trilogy, Sheev Palpatine/Luke Skywalker appears twice, as "Sheev Palpatine/Luke Skywalker (Original Trilogy)" and "Sheev Palpatine/Luke Skywalker (Star Wars Original Trilogy)".

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be fixed up now!

[sheliak]

Re: Star Trek novels, I would personally be happy to merge them all into Star Trek - Various Authors.

On the subject of merged comics, I'm also curious about alternate continuities--things like Marvel 1602 and Age of Apocalypse that stand apart from the main universe. Should those also be nominated just under Marvel Comics?

(Ah, sorry about the anon doublepost; I'd thought I was still logged in.)

[chocolateboxmod]

We would keep those separate as they're not in continuity with each other.

[wolffyluna]

I've spotted a duplicate in Shojou Kakumei Utena | Revolutionary Girl Utena:
Tenjou Utena/Himemiya Anthy (Revolutionary Girl Utena)
Himemiya Anthy/Tenjou Utena (Revolutionary Girl Utena)

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[teshumai]

I'm sorry our fandom is so difficult but you gave us two different answer for the same question:

(from crookedspoon regarding an comic in an alternate continuity of DC)
Does that mean comics apart from the main continuity like batman: white Knight would fall under dc comics?
-Thank you for that! And yes, that's right regarding comics.

(from Sheliak about alternate marvel continuities in general)
On the subject of merged comics, I'm also curious about alternate continuities--things like Marvel 1602 and Age of Apocalypse that stand apart from the main universe. Should those also be nominated just under Marvel Comics?
-We would keep those separate as they're not in continuity with each other.

Which way should we do it? all under the Company(Comics) tag with A/B(Alt. Continuity) for any disambiguation or Company(comics) referring only to the main continuity and Alt.Universe(comic) for the out of continuity series?

(sorry I forgot to sign in)

[chocolateboxmod]

The way we've decided to do it after discussion is this:

Titles that are in main continuity with each other are under the Marvel (Comics) and the DCU (Comics) tags, while titles that are not in main continuity are under individual titles. Consequently, for your examples, Marvel 1602 and Age of Apocalypse should be nominated (and in the case of Age of Apocalypse, approved) as separate titles.

Sorry we didn't make that clearer; comics are complicated and we say this as people who have been reading comics for a decade or so ourselves.

[fiachairecht]

Hi! I nominated Miriam Landisman/Arabella Whitlock (Undeadwood), Joanie/Miriam Landisman (Undeadwood), and Arabella Whitlock & Cynthia Whitlock (Undeadwood) under Undeadwood (Web Series), and AO3 synning changed them to be under Critical Role (Web Series). The two series are improperly synned, and while I'm not sure there's anything you can do to give me the Critical Role slots back (I did have actual Critical Role ships I wanted to nominate), but can you at least move those three ships into their own fandom?

My nominations page is https://archiveofourown.org/tag_sets/3721/nominations/136810 if you need it

[chocolateboxmod]

We think we've moved your nominations to "UnDeadwood (Web Series)", but let us know if your tags aren't showing up. In terms of your Critical Role ships we can manually insert them into the tagset; I'm afraid it's the best we can do.

[fencesit]

Duplicates in Castlevania (Cartoon)

Alucard | Adrian Tepes | Arikado Genya/Trevor Belmont/Sypha Belnades (Castlevania (Cartoon)
Alucard/Trevor Belmont/Sypha Belnades (Castlevania (Cartoon))

I would keep the bolded one because it's easier to read without the pipes and the cartoon is an american netflix production that never used Arikado Genya.

[fencesit]

Also, in The Witcher (TV)

Geralt of Rivia/Yennefer of Vengerberg (The Witcher (TV))
Geralt z Rivii | Geralt of Rivia/Yennefer z Vengerbergu | Yennefer of Vengerberg (The Witcher (TV))
Geralt z Rivii | Geralt of Rivia/Yennefer z Vengerbergu | Yennefer of Vengerberg (The Witcher TV)

I think the top, non-piped one is the one that should stay.

[narya_flame]

Sorry to be a pain, I spotted more duplicates - this time in the tagset for Little Women (2019):

Theodore "Laurie" Laurence/Josephine "Jo" March (Little Women 2019)

Theodore "Laurie" Laurence/Josephine March (Little Women 2019)

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[sheliak]

Tag wandering - Loki/Thor (MCU) is currently in Marvel (Comics).

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now.

[sirvalkyrie]

Superman Returns Earth is Earth-96 if you want to use Earth designations.

The Supergirl show is a core part of the Arrowverse. The Supergirl comics are not part of the Arrowverse. The Supergirl movie might be part of the Arrowverse as the events of Superman 1, 2, 3, and Returns happened on Earth-96 for sure, but we don't know if the Supergirl movie explicitly happened on it.

[ultra_fic]

Apologies for the typo in my own noms, that have since been approved.

Garcua Flynn & Jiya Marri (Timeless (TV 2016))

should be

Garcia Flynn & Jiya Marri (Timeless (TV 2016))

Thanks :)

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now.

[eggsbenedict]

Hiya, I spotted a couple of duplicates in Tekken (Video Games):

Hwoarang/Kazama Jin (Tekken)
Kazama Jin/Hwoarang (Tekken)

Lee Chaolan | Violet/Mishima Kazuya (Tekken)
Mishima Kazuya/Lee Chaolan (Tekken)

[chocolateboxmod]

The duplicates should be removed now!

[misspinkman]

Hi, I nominated Truth Be Told and got it approved and then found out according to IMDB i had spelled “Buhrman” incorrectly. I had it as “Berman”.

[chocolateboxmod]

May I ask you to provide the full text of the tags that need to be changed?

[surskitty]

Duplicates:

Poplar | Opal & Beet | Bede (Pokemon Main Video Game Series)
Sonia/Nessa (Pokemon MVGS)

[chocolateboxmod]

Sorry, I'm not sure I understand. Which one is the duplicate? They look to be different tags.

[facethestrange]

These tags from The Magicians (TV) don't specify the fandom:
23rd Timeline William "Penny" Adiyodi/Julia Wicker
Margo Hanson & Eliot Waugh
Quentin Coldwater & The Monster
Quentin Coldwater/Eliot Waugh
William "Penny" Adiyodi/Quentin Coldwater

[chocolateboxmod]

Are they in the right fandom?

[(Anonymous)]

In “Deus Ex (video games)” there are two of the following pairings:

Adam Jensen/Christian Jarreau
Jim Miller/Christian Jarreau

While “ Christian Jarreau“ is only mentioned once via e-mail he plays no role in the video game series but in the novel of “Deus Ex: Black Light”, which has its own category. The character itself is not in the video game series.

https://archiveofourown.org/tags/Deus%20Ex:%20Black%20Light%20-%20James%20Swallow/works

Jim Miller and Adam Jensen play roles in the book, so if possible can these pairings be moved to the Black Light category? Thanks!

~Kameiko

If it’s not that big of a deal please let me know!

[chocolateboxmod]

The book's not nominated, so I'm inclined to leave it in the video game tag. Otherwise I'd have to boot the tag completely.

[coaldustcanary]

Duplicates in The Man From UNCLE (2015):

Illya Kuryakin/Napoleon Solo (2015)
Illya Kuryakin/Napoleon Solo (UNCLE 2015)

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[coaldustcanary]

Duplicates in The Witcher (TV):

Geralt of Rivia/Jaskier (The Witcher (TV))
Geralt z Rivii | Geralt of Rivia/Jaskier | Dandelion (The Witcher (TV))

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[copacet]

Looks like there's a duplicate in Little Women (2019):

Theodore "Laurie" Laurence & Josephine March (Little Women 2019)
Theodore Laurence & Josephine March (Little Women 2019)

And in MCU:
Pietro Maximoff & Wanda Maximoff & Clint Barton (MCU)
Clint Barton & Pietro Maximoff & Wanda Maximoff (MCU)