Tagset closed and outstanding issues

[thecatmod]

...and that's a wrap on nominations! Currently we're at 1,626 fandoms with 12,192 relationships and more yet to be approved. Please check the tagset carefully for any duplications, migrations, or tags that just don't belong in a fandom at all. We need your fandom knowledge to help make this tagset as good as it can be!

 

If we have missed fixing up a tag or fandom, let us know! Please comment with your AO3 username if you are commenting anonymous.

There's been a lot going on on our side and it's entirely probable we've missed something what with all the 500 Error messages. See below for some of the outstanding issues:

• Beauty and the Beast - AMT - please choose a version.
• Chronicles of Narnia - AMT - please choose a version.
• Fullmetal Alchemist - AMT - please choose a version.
• HYYH | The Most Beautiful Moment in Life - is this different from BTS? If so, how?
• Should The Hornblower Story (Radio) and The Adventures of Horatio Hornblower (Radio) be separate?
• The Maze Runner Series - AMT - please choose a version.
• Persona Series - please nominate into individual Persona titles or into Persona 3.
• The Princess Diaries - AMT - please choose a version.
• Terminator movies - we have nominations for Terminator (Movies), Terminator Genisys, Dark Fate & Dark Faith (the latter is likely a typo). We've received some comments regarding different timelines; please confirm which movies form part of the same or different timelines.
• TOLKIEN J. R. R. - Works & Related Fandoms - This is too broad, please pick a narrower fandom.
• Twilight Series - AMT - please choose an adaptation.
• The Witcher - AMT - we think you mean the video game? Please nominate into Wiedźmin | The Witcher (Video Game), if so.

Edit: is Rapunzel Maximus (Tangled) meant to be '/' or '&'? Please link to your nominations page.

AMT/Related fandoms will be rejected if no response is received. If a relationship has been nominated under the incorrect fandom, it will also be deleted.

A letters post will be up later today.

Comments

[(Anonymous)]

Ok, so, the Watchmen (TV 2019) category has been approved by the wonderful people on archive, but if you go to the TV show tag set under “tv shows” there are two watchmen categories that need to be merged.

Watchmen (TV)
Watchmen (TV 2019)

According to archive: Watchmen (TV 2019) is the official cat.

https://archiveofourown.org/media/TV%20Shows/fandoms#letter-W

~Kameiko

Thank you :D thought I’d point this out!

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed now!

Repeated Tags

[(Anonymous)]

Bloom County has a duplicate- Michael Binkley/Milo Bloom

Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure has a duplicate- Leone Abbachio/Bruno Buccellati

Re: Repeated Tags

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[fiachairecht]

Duplicate in Fire Emblem Heroes
Peony/Sharena (Fire Emblem Heroes)
Peony/Sharon | Sharena (Fire Emblem Heroes)

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[hamimi_fk]

In the Steven Universe noms is this pairing:

Pearl/Pink Diamonds Pearl|Pink Pearl|Volleyball (Steven Universe)

It should be changed to:

Pearl/Pink Diamond's Pearl (this is the proper tag for the pairing)

[thecatmod]

The proper tag because it is the AO3 canonical or she's not not known by those names?

[sanguinity]

The Adventures of Horatio Hornblower is a radio show produced by CBS in the 1950s. The Hornblower Story is a BBC production from 1980 or so. Two separate productions, and while the plotlines coincide in many places (as they're both based on the same book series), they diverge in other places.

[thecatmod]

Thanks! They'll be approved separately.

[eggsbenedict]

Thanks for your hard work on this!

In Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne the "Dante/V (Devil May Cry)" tag has wandered, but it's already in Devil May Cry where it belongs.

There's a duplicate in Final Fantasy XV:
Lunafreya Nox Fleuret/Noctis Lucis Caelum (Final Fantasy XV)
Noctis Lucis Caelum/Lunafreya Nox Fleuret (Final Fantasy XV)

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be fixed up now!

[paspleurer]

I'm not the nominator, but HYYH is different from BTS as it is a fictional universe that takes place in their music videos and webtoons. The fictional characters share the same names as the BTS members, but it's widely considered to not be RPF as they are fictional characters within a fictional storyline.

[chocolateboxmod]

We have sent that one through now!

[hamimi_fk]

Dunno if this is worth pointing out, but...

American Horror Story is in both the Movies and TV Shows categories (should be umder TV Shows).

The same thing with Tennis no Oujisama | Prince of Tennis but it's in both Anime/Manga and TV Shows (should be under Anime/Manga).

[thecatmod]

Unfortunately we're unable to move fandoms between categories - that's reserved for AO3 tag wranglers (and neither of us are one!).

[hamimi_fk]

It's 3am and I finally did find something that can be helpful.

Welcome to Night Vale has a duplicate of Cecil Palmer/Carlos Ramirez (Welcome to Night Vale) and Carlos/Cecil Palmer.

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[paspleurer]

Under Fire Emblem: Fuukasetsugetsu | Fire Emblem: Three Houses (92), it looks like Claude von Riegan/Hilda Valentine Goneril (Fire Emblem: Three Houses) is a duplicate of Hilda Valentine Goneril/Claude von Riegan (Fire Emblem: Three Houses). Please let us know which one will be kept!

[chocolateboxmod]

We have kept Claude von Riegan/Hilda Valentine Goneril (Fire Emblem: Three Houses).

[narya_flame]

So excited for this! A few issues I spotted...

- Éowyn/Lothiriel is in the LOTR book tag set twice.
- Anakin Skywalker & Ahsoka Tano is in the Star Wars: The Clone Wars twice
- Cassian Andor & K-2SO is in the Rogue One tag set twice
- There are three tag sets that I think should all be for the same film: Little Women (2019), Little Woman (2019) and Little Women (Film 2019).

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be fixed up now! May we ask in future that you provide the full tag text so that we can find the tags quicker?

Duplicates

[chicago_ruth]

Hades (video game):
Chaos/Zagreus (Hades Video Game)
Zagreus/Chaos (Hades Video Game)

Re: Duplicates

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[thisbluespirit]

Duplicates in Doctor Who (2005):

Thirteenth Doctor/Yasmin Kahn (Doctor Who (2005)) Thirteenth Doctor/Yasmin Khan (Doctor Who (2005))

(And it's Yasmin Khan, not Kahn).

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[merle_p]

Under Movies, there's a duplicate in "Hair":

George Berger/Claude Bukowski (Hair)
George Berger/Claude Bukowski

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[(Anonymous)]

Thank you so much for all your hard work on this! A very minor note:

Anaheim Angels and Minnesota Twins RPF should be under ‘celebrities and real people’ (they’re currently uncategorized).

Thanks!

Sharksdontsleep

[chocolateboxmod]

We're not able to categorize fandoms into media categories; that's something that only AO3 tag wranglers can do and neither of us are one.

[slippery_fish]

Regarding Terminator: Dark Fate and Genisys are definitely different timelines and have nothing to do with each other.

With "Terminator (Movies)" it's hard to say because the nominators might have just gone with the AO3 set-up and used it to nominate characters from Dark Fate or Genisys or Salvation. Or they mean the first two movies. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Maybe this helps you (in case the actual nominators don't comment):
If Dani Ramos, Grace, Carl or Rev 9 are mentioned, those are specific Dark Fate characters.

[thecatmod]

Is Terminator: Dark Fate a direct sequel to Terminator 1 & 2? Or can we categorise it more like the various Star Wars trilogies?

[asymptotically]

Some duplicates in Star Wars Legends: The Old Republic (Video Game)

Andronikos Revel/Male Sith Inquisitor (Star Wars Legends: The Old Republic)
Andronikos Revel/Male Sith Inquisitor (SWTOR)

Theron Shan/Male Sith Warrior (Star Wars: The Old Republic)
Theron Shan/Male Sith Warrior (SWTOR)

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[slippy]

The book The Collared Knight - Tara McGolden has a nom for a single character: Farnesse (The Collared Knight - Tara McGolden)

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[ultra_fic]

Typo:
under Agent Carter (TV)
Peggy Carter & Boardinhouse Residents (Agent Carter)
should read
Peggy Carter & Boardinghouse Residents (Agent Carter)

Duplicate:
under Marvel Cinematic Universe - Peggy Carter/Steve Rogers (MCU)
under Crossover Fandom - Peggy Carter/Steve Rogers (AC/MCU)

Duplicate:
under White Collar - Neal Burke & Neal Caffrey
under White Collar - Neal Caffrey & Neal Burke

:)

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[laughingpineapple]

There's a duplicate in Final Fantasy VI!

Mog & Umaro (FFVI)
Umaro & Mog (Final Fantasy VI)

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[ninety6tears]

Oops - there is a single character tag I accidentally nominated for Dublin Murder Squad - French.

Grace Corrigan | Lexie Madison (Dublin Murder Squad)

Star Trek AOS has a duplicate.

James T. Kirk/Spock (Star Trek AOS)
James T. Kirk/Spock (Star Trek: Alternate Original Series)

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[delphi]

A few duplicates:

Little Women Series - Louisa May Alcott
Friedrich Bhaer/Josephine March (Little Women - Alcott)
Friedrich Bhaer/Josephine March (Little Women Series - Louisa May Alcott)

Avatar: Legend of Korra
Lin Beifong & Suyin Beifong (ALoK)
Lin Beifong & Suyin Beifong (Legend of Korra)

Hair (1979)
George Berger/Claude Bukowski (Hair)
George Berger/Claude Bukowski

A League of Their Own (1992)
Dottie Hinson & Kit Keller (ALoTO 1992)
Dottie Hinson & Kit Keller (A League of Their Own)
and
Jimmy Dugan/Dottie Hinson (A League of Their Own)
Jimmy Dugan/Dottie Hinson (ALoTO 1992)

X-Men (Alternate Timeline Movies)
Erik Lehnsherr & Peter Maximoff (X-Men (ATM)
Erik Lehnsherr & Peter Maximoff (X-Men: ATM)

Little Women (2019)
Amy March & Josephine "Jo" March (Little Women 2019)
Amy March & Josephine March (Little Women 2019)
and
Amy March/Theodore Laurence (Little Women 2019)
Theodore Laurence/Amy March (Little Women 2019)
and
Jo March & Theodore Laurence (Little Women 2019)
Theodore Laurence & Josephine March (Little Women 2019)
and
Friedrich Bhaer/Josephine March (Little Women 2019)
Jo March/Friedrich Bhaer (Little Women 2019)
and
Josephine March & Margaret March (Little Women 2019)
Meg March & Jo March (Little Women 2019)

Also, there's a crossover pairing in the Harry Potter section: Jane Marple/Minerva McGonagall. It looks like this one's already also under Crossover Fandom, although without the fandom indicators.

There are also two single character nominations under Letters for Lucardo (Graphic Novels):
Ed Fiedler (Letters for Lucardo (Graphic Novels)
Lucardo von Gishaupt (Letters for Lucardo (Graphic Novels))

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[rebecca2525]

James Bond (Craig Movies) have wandered into the Books category. It's probably because James Bond the character is missing his disambiguation.

[chocolateboxmod]

May I ask for the full text of the tag?

[polarizing]

Duplications found

Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon (Anime & Manga)
Chiba Mamoru/Tsukino Usagi (Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon)
Tsukino Usagi/Chiba Mamoru (Sailor Moon)

快盗戦隊ルパンレンジャー VS 警察戦隊パトレンジャー | Kaitou Sentai Lupinranger VS Keisatsu Sentai Patoranger
Asaka Keiichiro/Yano Kairi (LuPat)
Asaka Keiichirou/Yano Kairi (Lupinranger VS Patoranger)

[polarizing]

Another one, sorry for double post

In Steven Universe:
Amethyst/Peridot (Steven Universe)
Peridot/Amethyst (Steven Universe)

[theladyscribe]

Found a duplicate in the hockey RPF tags!

Travis Konecny/Nolan Patrick (Hockey RPF)
Travis Konecny/Nolan Patrick (Men's Hockey RPF)

ETA: I also found several duplicates in the Pitch (TV 2016) tags:

Ginny Baker/Livan Duarte/Mike Lawson (Pitch TV)
Ginny Baker/Livan Duarte/Mike Lawson (Pitch)
Ginny Baker/Mike Lawson/Livan Duarte (Pitch 2016)

Ginny Baker/Mike Lawson (Pitch 2016)
Ginny Baker/Mike Lawson (Pitch TV)
Ginny Baker/Mike Lawson (Pitch)

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be fixed up now!