Further Nominations Clarifications

[chocolateboxmod]

 Remember, nominations close at 11:59pm EST on December 29, so please get your nominations in before then!

And now, some clarifications. Some of these have been outstanding a while and if they are not clarified by the time signups open then I will have to reject them.

Aldnoah.Zero
Could the nominator for the following tags please give me a bit more information about these tags? They look like worldbuilding to me and I'm not really sure how they fit an exchange with our focus. Happy to be persuaded otherwise!

• Earthlings & Versians
• Vers & Mars

Crossover Fandoms
Could the nominators for the following tags please confirm which iteration of characters you intended to nominate as it is unclear:

• Clark Kent (DC) & Twelfth Doctor (Doctor Who) - Which Clark?
• Doctor Strange & Dumbledore - Which Doctor Strange?
• Harleen Quinzel & Wade Wilson - Which Harley and which Wade?
• Harleen Quinzel/Wade Wilson - Which Harley and which Wade?
• James "Bucky" Barnes/Dean Winchester - Which Bucky?
• Kaylee Frye/Montgomery "Scotty" Scott - Which Scotty?
• Loki (Marvel) & Mad Hatter|Jefferson - Which Loki?
• Parker (Leverage) & Deadpool - Which Deadpool?
• Red Riding Hood | Ruby/Natasha Romanov - Which Natasha?

DCU
Could the nominator for DCU (that is, not DCU (Comics) but DCU) please revise your nomination? It looks like under one fandom nomination you have DC Comics, The Flash (TV), Batman Beyond, Gotham (maybe?), possibly the Vertigo imprint of The Authority (unless you mean reboot Midnighter and Apollo) and some others as well. This is too broad a category and further it's unclear which incarnation of the characters you mean. Please revise your nomination to nominate characters under more specific fandoms. The tagset may be able to help you if you're not sure what categories you could use.

Doctor Who
There are currently three separate groups in the tagset: Doctor Who the overarching tag, one for the original series and one for the reboot. Do you want them under the "Doctor Who" overarching tag or split into the original series and the reboot?

Marvel Cinematic Universe
Could the nominator for these tags please nominate these under Crossover Fandoms:

• Clint Barton & Deadpool
• Peter Parker/Wade Wilson

Shinreigari GHOST HOUND
Could the nominator for the following tags please give me a bit more information about them? On first reading they look to be prompts rather than relationship tags.

• Astral Projection & Childhood Trauma
• Komori Tarou & Dreaming
• Nakajima Masayuki & Self-loathing
• Oogami Makoto & Komori Tarou & Family Trauma

Star Wars
The poll is still going and will continue until 12:01am on the 28th (or when I pry myself from Final Fantasy XV, whichever comes second). Whichever doesn't win the vote out of AMT or individual series will not be approved, rejected or amended, so that the nominators have the ability to change their nom(s).

X-Men Movieverse
How do you want to split this? Putting it all in one tag with disambig tags, or separate it out into individual timelines? Or something else?

Also! If there is tagset drift, please let me know! This is especially a problem for Marvel and DC products, Tolkien, and crossovers. Thanks!

Comments

[(Anonymous)]

There's another dup relationship under Fullmetal Alchemist (Anime 2003): "Edward Elric/Roy Mustang (2003 anime)" and "Edward Elric/Roy Mustang (Anime 2003)".

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed now!

[primeideal]

If I wanted to nominate characters from "Harry Potter and the Cursed Child" (a theater spinoff of the Harry Potter series), where would that go?

[chocolateboxmod]

It looks like there's a canonical tag for Harry Potter and the Cursed Child, so you can nominate under that! Also, it'd be really appreciated if you were to nominate it as "Character A & Character B (Cursed Child)" or Character A/Character B (Cursed Child)" or something like that to speed up nomination approval.

[sirvalkyrie]

I'd like the X-Men movieverse combined with disambig tags.


Clark Kent (DC) & Twelfth Doctor (Doctor Who) is mine. I wanted more just general Clark rather than a specific one. It's inspired by a scene in the recent Doctor Who Christmas special where the Doctor figures out that Clark Kent is Superman. If it's too broad I'll just remove the nomination.

[primeideal]

Thanks. If one of the characters is new in that canon, but another was previously introduced in the Harry Potter books, should I nominate that as a crossover or just under (Cursed Child)?

[trobadora]

There are currently three separate groups in the tagset: Doctor Who the overarching tag, one for the original series and one for the reboot. Do you want them under the "Doctor Who" overarching tag or split into the original series and the reboot?

Doctor Who (2005) isn't a reboot, it's a continuation. So as one of the nominators, I'd be happy to have them all just under "Doctor Who". But either way works for me!

[chocolateboxmod]

Under Cursed Child, please!

[kalloway]

Ardyn Izunia/Ignis Scientia
Gladiolus Amicitia/Ignis Scientia
Noctis Lucis Caelum/Ignis Scientia

are all hanging out in Kingdom Hearts after apparently road-tripping over from Final Fantasy XV.

[(Anonymous)]

Sorry to be a pain, but I apparently screwed up my Midsomer Murder noms. I put them under "Midsomer Murders - All Media Types" when they should actually be in "Midsomer Murders (TV)". Is it possible for that to be fixed?

[zdenka]

Galadriel | Artanis/Tauriel (Hobbit Movies) is correctly in Hobbit - AMT but has also wandered into

The Lord of the Rings - J. R. R. Tolkien
The Silmarillion and other histories of Middle-Earth - J. R. R. Tolkien

[(Anonymous)]

Same.

[(Anonymous)]

I think don't split up doctor who and X-Men. Pretty much same reason I gave for Star wars.

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed now!

[(Anonymous)]

SA

By 'same' I meant I also prefer merged X-Men Original and Alternate Timeline under one fandom tag (Movieverse), disambiguation in brackets whenever needed. But I'm OK if people prefer them separate.

[chocolateboxmod]

I think those are fixed up now! If I could ask you to have a look and make sure, that would be great!

[chocolateboxmod]

Well, it's not the most elegant solution that I've come up with, but hopefully that has stopped that tag drift. Can I ask you to check and let me know if it's moved? Thank you!

[chocolateboxmod]

I'm sorry, but you're anonymous and so it's harder for me to find your comment in my inbox. Could I please ask you to link those reasons here? Thank you!

[zdenka]

It seems to be correct now!

[melody_jade]

I will prefer the X-Men nominations to be split into X-Men (Alternate Timeline Movies) and X-Men (Original Timeline Movies).

The problem though is that some of the current X-Men movieverse tags are ambiguous and it's not clear whether they should be under ATM or OTM.

These are the nominations that are definitely under X-Men (ATM), and there's probably already some overlap:
Alex Summers & Scott Summers
Armando Muñoz/Alex Summers
Betsy Braddock/Ororo Munroe
Erik Lehnsherr & Nina
Jean Grey & Jubilation Lee & Ororo Munroe
Jean Grey & Peter Maximoff & Ororo Munroe & Scott Summers & Kurt Wagner
Ms. Maximoff & Peter Maximoff
Peter Maximoff & Wanda Maximoff & Unnamed Younger Sister
Peter Maximoff & Wanda Maximoff

I nominated David Haller & Charles Xavier and if the fandom is split I'll prefer for it to go under X-Men (ATM)

John Allerdyce/Erik Lehnsherr is definitely part of the original timeline (OTM). Clarice Ferguson/Kitty Pryde too.

I'm less certain about the remaining. I can make guesses for some of them (Logan/Scott is probably OTM, for example), but I can't be 100% certain.

If you do decide to split by timeline (and if the original nominator doesn't come forward), a possible fix might be to duplicate the ambiguous nominations into both ATM and OTM?

ETA: Or if that's too much work, putting everything into one single X-Men (movies) tag with disambiguation where needed will work too. The problem with the current setup is that there are X-Men (ATM) ships both in the X-Men (Movieverse) category and in the X-Men (ATM) category.

[primeideal]

Atobe Keigo (Prince of Tennis)/Hermione Granger (Harry Potter) is showing up in the HP books tag. Looks like a straight-up crossover to me.

[(Anonymous)]

Fixed perfectly! I'm very sorry for making more work for you, thank you so much for being an awesome mod!

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now, thanks!

[(Anonymous)]

I'm sorry about the slip-up, but I accidentally nominated 'Finduilas of Dol Amroth (LotR)/Uinen (Silmarillion)' as 'Finduilas of Dol Amroth (Silmarillion)/Uinen (LotR)' under Crossover Fandom; the tag should be the former, not the latter

[(Anonymous)]

Psst, the nominations for Terminator Genisys and Terminator Genisys (2015) can no doubt be merged.

[rubylily]

There's a duplicate under Anime & Manga: "Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon" and "Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon (Anime & Manga)."

More MCU Corrections

[(Anonymous)]

"Natasha Romanov & Steve Rogers" is a duplicate of "Steve Rogers & Natasha Romanov".

Additionally, some crossover tags have wandered in there.

Rumiko Fujikawa appears to be a character from the comics, who has never appeared in the MCU, but appears in these MCU tags:
Rumiko Fujikawa/Steve Rogers/Tony Stark
Rumiko Fujikawa/Tony Stark

Siobhan "Mrs. S" Sadler appears to be a character from the BBC TV show Orphan Black, but appears in this MCU tag:
Maria Hill/Siobhan "Mrs. S" Sadler

[chocolateboxmod]

Indeed they can and have been! Are you able to check to see whether there's any duplication of tags with the merging? Thanks!

[chocolateboxmod]

Not a problem, that's been fixed now. Can I ask you to check to see whether the tag is correct and where it should be? Thanks!

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed now!

Re: More MCU Corrections

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be fixed now!

[(Anonymous)]

It looks fine, thank you!

[sidewinder]

I see that John Munch is causing a lot of tag drift problems, as usual! Let me see if I can hunt them all down so far:

These only belong in Law & Order: SVU, but have also drifted into Law & Order and Homicide:Life on the Street:
- Brian Cassidy/John Munch
- John Munch & Odafin "Fin" Tutuola
- John Munch/Odafin "Fin" Tutuola
- Monique Jefferies/John Munch
- Olivia Benson & John Munch

These only belong in Homicide: LOTS but have drifted as well into SVU:
- Kay Howard/John Munch
- Tim Bayliss/John Munch

This belongs in Law & Order (where it was nominated although theoretically it can go in others), but has drifted into SVU and HLOTS as well:
- Lennie Briscoe/John Munch

[chocolateboxmod]

I think I've fixed those up! Could I ask you to take a look at those for me and let me know if John Munch's unfortunately eventful career has caused him or others to drift into more tags?

[sidewinder]

Looks all sorted now, thanks! I don't see any other drift problems thanks to his multifandom exploits ;)