Tag Set Vetting

[chocolateboxmod]

Nominations are finished! We have, at last count, 14,891 relationships nominated across 1,340 fandoms.

First up, I'm not able to edit the tagset. AO3 is aware of the problem, but I'm also aware that we'd like to open signups on time! What I propose to do is do my best to keep an eye on it, and the minute I'm able to get into the console (which might happen), I will triage certain fixes as being essential. This is the order I plan to edit the tagset:

• Removal of duplicates and unassociated tags
• Deleting and recreating wandering tags
• Merging/splitting fandoms
• Any other changes.

Signups will not open until all identified duplicates are removed. I'll try doing the rest, but I'm keen to open on the 1st.

To make this faster for me and thus maximize my chances of getting everything done, I'm going to leave comments to this post. If you have identified a problem that needs to be changed, comment in reply to that comment only please!

Finally, some last queries:

• Eleventh Doctor/The Master (Delgado) - Did Roger Delgado's Master appear in Doctor Who (2005)?
• Tyrion Lannister & Varys (ASoIaF) - you've nominated this under Game of Thrones. Are you fine with me fixing that to be Varys (GoT)?
• A Song of Ice and Fire & Related Fandoms - Did you mean A Song of Ice and Fire - George R. R. Martin, or Game of Thrones?
• DCU - Which version for these characters?
• Star Wars Sequel Trilogy - Does Anakin Skywalker or Yoda appear in The Last Jedi (Please provide a yes/no answer only; I want to see it soon!)
• Gorogoa (Video Game) - Did you nominate relationships for this game?
• Hohokum (Video Game) - Did you nominate relationships for this game?

Comments

Removal of Duplicate Tags and associating unassociated tags

[chocolateboxmod]

Re: Removal of Duplicate Tags and associating unassociated tags

[(Anonymous)]

Duplicate under "Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008) - All Media Types": Anakin Skywalker & Ahsoka Tano (Clone Wars), Anakin Skywalker & Ahsoka Tano (Star Wars: Clone Wars)

Re: Removal of Duplicate Tags and associating unassociated tags

[(Anonymous)]

Under "Dark Tower - Stephen King"

Cuthbert Allgood/Roland Deschain (Dark Tower - King)
Cuthbert Allgood/Roland Deschain (Dark Tower - Stephen King)

Re: Removal of Duplicate Tags and associating unassociated tags

[(Anonymous)]

Under Star Wars Sequel Trilogy:

Chewbacca & Porgs
Chewbacca & The Porgs (Sequel Trilogy)

Re: Removal of Duplicate Tags and associating unassociated tags

[streussal]

Under Riverdale tv:

Cheryl Blossom & Veronica Lodge (Riverdale (2017))
Cheryl Blossom & Veronica Lodge (Riverdale)

Cheryl Blossom/Toni Topaz (Riverdale (2017))
Cheryl Blossom/Toni Topaz (Riverdale)

Cheryl Blossom/Veronica Lodge (Riverdale (TV 2014))
Cheryl Blossom/Veronica Lodge (Riverdale (TV 2017))

Re: Removal of Duplicate Tags and associating unassociated tags

[(Anonymous)]

Worick Arcangelo & Nicolas Brown & Alex Benedetto, which is currently unassociated, should belong under Gangsta. (Anime & Manga). Thank you!

Re: Removal of Duplicate Tags and associating unassociated tags

[deathsblood]

Under Baby Driver (2017):

Darling | Monica/Debora (Baby Driver (2017))
Darling | Monica/Debora (Baby Driver)

are the same.

Re: Removal of Duplicate Tags and associating unassociated tags

[(Anonymous)]

Under Harry Potter:
Luna Lovegood/Ginny Weasley (Harry Potter - Rowling)
Luna Lovegood/Ginny Weasley (Potter - Rowling)

Under Star Trek AOS:
Leonard "Bones" McCoy/Spock (ST:AOS)
Leonard "Bones" McCoy/Spock (Star Trek AOS)

Under Star Trek Discovery:
Michael Burnham & Spock (ST:D)
Michael Burnham & Spock (TOS)

Re: Removal of Duplicate Tags and associating unassociated tags

[esteliel]

Under "Les Misérables - Victor Hugo":

Javert/Jean Valjean (Le Misérables - Hugo)
Javert/Jean Valjean (Les Misérables - Victor Hugo)

Re: Removal of Duplicate Tags and associating unassociated tags

[klutzygirl]

Axl Heck/Lexie and Sean Donahue/Sue Heck should be in The Middle. They're currently unassociated.

Re: Removal of Duplicate Tags and associating unassociated tags

[(Anonymous)]

Duplicate under Corruption of Champions (video games):

Female Champion/Erlking
Female Champion/Erlking (Corruption of Champions)

Re: Removal of Duplicate Tags and associating unassociated tags

[sixbeforelunch]

Under Agent Carter (TV):

Peggy Carter & Angie Martinelli (Agent Carter (TV))
Peggy Carter & Angie Martinelli (Agent Carter)
Peggy Carter & Angie Martinelli

Re: Removal of Duplicate Tags and associating unassociated tags

[(Anonymous)]

Duplicate under Game of Thrones (TV):


Oberyn Martell/Jon Snow (Game of Thrones)
Oberyn Martell/Jon Snow (GoT)

Re: Removal of Duplicate Tags and associating unassociated tags

[(Anonymous)]

Can you please removed Male Human/Egg-laying Alien (my nomination)? I just noticed that Tentacle Ovipository Alien/Male Human Character is already in the tagset, and it's the same thing.

Deleting and Recreating Wandering Tags

[chocolateboxmod]

Re: Deleting and Recreating Wandering Tags

[yuuago]

Wandering tag under Small Trolls (Webcomic):
Sakari Harmonsuo & Veeti Harmonsuo (Year in Hereafter)

I see that this tag has also been properly nominated under Year in Hereafter (Webcomic), so it could be just deleted from the Small Trolls tags rather than deleted/moved to YiH.

Caveat: I'm not the original nominator, so this one is tricky, because there are indeed characters in the Small Trolls comic with these exact same names (Sakari Harmonsuo & Veeti Harmonsuo). Sakari has only appeared in the concept art so far but he does exist in that world. SO I'm not actually sure if the nominator actually did intend to nom the Small Trolls version of this gen relationship, or if the tag did wander from the Year in Hereafter section somehow.

Merging/Splitting Fandoms

[chocolateboxmod]

Re: Merging/Splitting Fandoms

[(Anonymous)]

I think "Star Wars Legends: X-wing Series - Aaron Allston & Michael Stackpole" should be merged into "Star Wars Legends: X-wing Series - All Media Types". It looks like the ships have been wandering between them, as it is. And as someone who was planning to request/offer, having two separate fandoms is a pain. It doesn't look like there are even 20 nominated ships, so it should be easy enough to avoid the comic exclusive characters if someone only wants book characters.

Other Changes

[chocolateboxmod]

Re: Other Changes

[(Anonymous)]

In Killjoys (TV), Dutch & Khylen & Aneela is a typo. It should be:

Dutch & Khlyen & Aneela

[(Anonymous)]

Yoda yes, Anakin no.

[chocolateboxmod]

Thank you!

[graveexcitement]

Not the nominator, but Yoda does appear in The Last Jedi. Anakin Skywalker does not.

[(Anonymous)]

Delgado!Master does not show up in Doctor Who 2005.

[chocolateboxmod]

Thank you!

[rodo]

Tyrion Lannister & Varys (ASoIaF) - you've nominated this under Game of Thrones. Are you fine with me fixing that to be Varys (GoT)?

I wanted Game of Thrones but the AO3 told me that was the canonical realtionship tag, so I chose that instead. I saw you already fixed this, but just in case you were wondering.

[chocolateboxmod]

Yeah, I figured, but just wanted to check. Thank you!

[(Anonymous)]

Hello dear mod :)

A Song of Ice and Fire & Related Fandoms: I meant either one or both.

Yoda appears in tlj but Anakin doesn't.

[chocolateboxmod]

Thanks for that - in looking at your tags there were characters with significant differences between the book and show, and so I wanted to be sure you were okay with getting either.

[elleth]

In The Lord of the Rings - J. R. R. Tolkien:
Fíriel of Gonder/Malbeth (LotR - Tolkien) has a typo, should be Fíriel of Gondor

In The Silmarillion and other histories of Middle-Earth - J. R. R. Tolkien:
Lúthien Tinúviel/Thuringwethil (Silmarillion0 also has a typo instead of a closing parenthesis

In Stand Still, Stay Silent:
Eino Hotakainen & Tuuli Hotakainen & Veeti Hotakainen this should be Eino Hotakainen & Tuuli Hollola & Veeti Hollola, the last names got mixed up.

Agneta/Sigrun Eide (SSSS) and Agneta/Sigrun Eide is a duplicate.

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be fixed up now!

[(Anonymous)]

I nominated several tags with Kishinami Hakuno under Fate Stay Night & Related Fandoms. Another nominator specified Female Hakuno. I was thinking female Hakuno but didn't specify male or female. Is it fine to request female without changing those tags?

[chocolateboxmod]

You can request female Hakuno, but it would be considered an optional detail - one that your creator can follow or not as they choose.

[rosefox]

Piper (ST:TOS) & Sarda (ST:TOS) & Merete (ST:TOS) & Scanner (ST:TOS) was nominated under ST:TOS, but I think it should actually be under Star Trek - Various Authors; they're from tie-in novels.

Also, would you like info on how best to categorize some of the uncategorized fandoms?

[chocolateboxmod]

I've moved that tag across now.

While I appreciate your offer, I'm not able to categorize fandoms. Only AO3 tag wranglers can do that!