Nominations Closed - Queries

[thecatmod]

Thank you to everyone who has commented about duplicates/spelling/etc. We're still working on a few of the outstanding comments, however there's a few queries to resolve:

• Did the Marvel 1616 nominator mean 616? 16161? The only 1616 we could find related to this. 
• Kochou Shinobu/Tomioka Giyuu (Kimetsu no Yaiba) - nominator, did you nominate this in the anime or the manga? It's gone wandering and we don't know where it should go.
• The Hobbit - All Media Types - nominator, please pick a version.
• The nominator who put "Female Tabris/Morrigan (Dragon Age)" as a fandom - we will correct your fandom and send it through once you confirm which relationship you're dropping of the eight you've included in here.

Chocobox App v1.0 is live thanks to the work of karanguni! As we are still finalizing our tagset, the app is not final, but feel free to test it out and report bugs so that the app can be made stronger, faster, and more terrifying with each iteration. Bugs can be reported here.

Anon comments are screened unless you comment with your AO3 name.

Comments

[kore]

If the Marvel nom is me I did indeed mean 616, the regular comicsverse, not 1616 and I don't know what I was thinking. //facepalm

[thecatmod]

Can you link to your nominations? Thank you!

[kore]

Whoops, sure thing! https://archiveofourown.org/tag_sets/5277/nominations/179601

[thecatmod]

This should be fixed now!

[donutsweeper]

just an an FYI, the 'The Magnificent Seven' nom appears to be for the movie rather than the TV show (which is how it's appearing in the tagset). The characters Billy Rocks and Goodnight Robicheaux did not appear in the show.

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed now!

Noms Clarifications

[gloriousgoblinqueen]

Hi, I'm the one with the Marvel characters in my Crossover Fandom nomination. I wanted to link you to it (sorry for the late reply, email filter was wonky).

https://archiveofourown.org/tag_sets/5277/nominations/180588

I also wanted to clarify that my nom for That 70s Show should be That '70s Show (forgot the apostrophe). Thanks!

Re: Noms Clarifications

[chocolateboxmod]

We've fixed up That '70s show!

[(Anonymous)]

Spotted a duplicate in Inception:
Ariadne/Robert Fischer (Inception)
Ariadne/Robert Fisher (Inception)

Hi! One of my noms “Jack Kline & Dean Winchester (Supernatural)” is not showing in the tag set, even though it was approved. This may be because I got the alphabetization wrong and should have typed “Dean Winchester & Jack Kline (Supernatural)”? That’s not showing in the tag set either.

Here’s the link to my noms if you need it: https://archiveofourown.org/tag_sets/5277/nominations/179388

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[sheliak]

Typo in Magnus Chase and the Gods of Asgard - Rick Riordan

Blitzen & Magnus Chase and Hearthstone (Magnus Chase - Riordan)

should probably be

Blitzen & Hearthstone & Magnus Chase (Magnus Chase - Riordan)

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[(Anonymous)]

Duplicates:

Cobra Kai (Web Series):

Daniel LaRusso/Johnny Lawrence (Cobra Kai (Web Series))
Daniel LaRusso/Johnny Lawrence (Cobra Kai)

John Kreese/Johnny Lawrence (Cobra Kai (Web Series))
John Kreese/Johnny Lawrence (Cobra Kai)

Thanks!

~Kameiko

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[fair_feather_friend]

Typo in this tag:
Male gobin theif/Male human prince (Original Work)
Male gobin thief/Male human prince (Original Work)

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[scripsi]

In The Mummy series there is both Ardeth Bay/Evy Carnahan O’Connell/Rick O’Connell and the a duplicate pairing with Evelyn instead of Evy. It’s the same character and both names are used in the movie. Though even if Evelyn is the full name, Evy is used the most.

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed now!

[feroxargentea]

This tag seems to be a typo, with the fandom name there twice(?)

Aphrodite/Gabrielle (Xena) (Xena: Warrior Princess)

[chocolateboxmod]

May we ask if the characters names are spelled correctly? Or is it the two things in brackets?

[feroxargentea]

It's the two things in brackets. The names are correct. (Not my nomination though.)

[chocolateboxmod]

We will leave that alone then - with a tagset of this size, it's difficult to open the admin console to make the necessary edits. Thanks for letting us know!

[thedevilchicken]

Some wandering tags, in case it helps!

Appearing in both 陈情令 | The Untamed (TV) and 魔道祖师 - 墨香铜臭 | Módào Zǔshī - Mòxiāng Tóngxiù with no disambig: Jin Guangyao/Xue Yang

Appearing in both Twilight Series - All Media Types and Twilight Series - Stephenie Meyer: Demetri/Felix (Twilight); Alec & Jane (Twilight); Demetri/Felix/Heidi (Twilight)

Appearing in both Mortal Kombat - All Media Types and Mortal Kombat (Video Games): Mileena/Tanya (Mortal Kombat); Rain/Tanya (Mortal Kombat); Shao Kahn/Sindel (Mortal Kombat)

Appearing in both 沙海 | Tomb of the Sea (TV) and 盗墓笔记重启 | The Lost Tomb Reboot (TV): Li Cu/Wu Xie (DMBJ Series)

Appearing in both Pikmin (Video Game) and Super Smash Brothers: Louie/Olimar (Pikmin)

Appearing twice in 聖剣伝説 LEGEND OF MANA | Seiken Densetsu: Legend of Mana (Video Game) for some bizarre reason: Daena & Escad & Irwin & Matilda (Legend of Mana)

Appearing in both Cthulhu Mythos - H. P. Lovecraft and Mansions of Madness (Board Game): Nyarlathotep/Yhoundeh (Cthulhu Mythos)

Appearing in both Karate Kid (Movies) and Cobra Kai (Web Series): Daniel LaRusso/Robby Keene (Cobra Kai)

Appearing in both Power Rangers (2017) and Mighty Morphin Power Rangers: Kimberly Hart/Trini (Power Rangers 2017)

Appearing in both Dragon Age (Comics) and Dragon Age (Video Games): Alistair/Female Warden (Dragon Age); Alistair/Morrigan (Dragon Age); Isabela/Leliana (Dragon Age); Shale/Sten (Dragon Age)

[chocolateboxmod]

We have fixed up the Pikmin, Mana, Cthulhu, Cobra Kai, Power Rangers, and Dragon Age nominations. We're not sure we're going to have time to make queries for the others, and it's arguable that they could be in either.

[lemonsharks]

I swear i miss nominations every year

*slow clap for me*

[malachiical]

It looks like "An Elderly Lady Up To No Good - Helene Tursten" should be "An Elderly Lady Is Up to No Good - Helene Tursten" instead!

Also, similar to That '70s show which you fixed above, "Black 47 (2018)" should be "Black '47 (2018)."

Finally, "The Walk (Movie 2014)" should be "The Walk (Movie 2015)." Usually this would be a minor detail but there was actually a movie called The Walk that came out in 2014 as well and was a totally different thing.

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be sorted out now!

[aranciata]

Props to the mods for handling such a huge tagset!!

I noticed some minor typos in a few of the ジョジョの奇妙な冒険 | JoJo no Kimyou na Bouken | JoJo's Bizarre Adventure relationship tags; the series has been put in brackets as “JoJo’s Bizarre Adventures” for the following relationships, when Adventure should be singular:

- Narancia Ghirga/Trish Una
- Giorno Giovanna/Guido Mista
- Giorno Giovanna/Narancia Ghirga
- Hot Pants & Lucy Steel
- Caesar Anthonio Zeppeli/Joseph Joestar

[chocolateboxmod]

Thank you for bringing that to our attention! We're leaving disambiguations alone, because they are really to ensure tags don't wander and, if they do, we know where they should be placed.

[rosecake]

Sorry, I think this was my fault, but the 1988 anime version of Legend of the Galactic Heroes is currently listed as two separate fandoms under the tag set. Could they be combined? The canonical tag is "Ginga Eiyuu Densetsu | Legend of the Galactic Heroes", but there are several different adaptations and versions of the story now so I was trying to disambiguate it. I didn't realize there was already a sorted tag in use, sorry!

Right now it's under this tag in Anime:
Ginga Eiyuu Densetsu | Legend of the Galactic Heroes (Anime 1988)
* Reinhard von Lohengramm/Siegfried Kircheis (LOGH)


And then also in Uncategorized Fandoms:
Legend of the Galactic Heroes (1988 OVA)
*Dusty Attemborough/Yang Wen-li (LOGH)
*Frederica Greenhill/Neidhart Muller (LOGH)
*Frederica Greenhill/Walter von Schonkopf/Yang Wen-li (LOGH)
*Frederica Greenhill/Yang Wen-li (LOGH)
*Jean Robert Lappe/Jessica Edwards/Yang Wen-li (LOGH)
*Oskar von Reuenthal/Wolfgang Mittermeyer (LOGH)
*Walter von Schonkopf/Yang Wen-li (LOGH)

Here's a link to my noms: https://archiveofourown.org/tag_sets/5277/nominations/181065

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now!

[rosecake]

Thank you ♥

[alexseanchai]

bit late I guess but there's a duplicate under Original Works:

Crown Princess Who Was A Starving Writer In Her Former Life/Faraway King Who's A Fan Of Her Books
Crown Princess Who Was A Starving Writer In Her Youth/Faraway King Who's A Fan Of Her Books (OW)