Tagset Queries - Post 3

[chocolateboxmod]

Back again for yet another set of queries and requests! This will likely be our last one before nominations close, so please help us finalize the tagset!

• Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon/Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon (Anime and Manga) - we think this is the same thing. Can you please confirm if it is, so we can merge them together?
• Chronicles of Narnia - AMT - please choose a version.
• Fullmetal Alchemist - AMT - please choose a version
• Persona Series - please nominate into individual Persona titles or into Persona 3.
• Star Wars - AMT - please choose a more narrow fandom.
• Terminator movies - we have nominations for Terminator (Movies), Terminator Genisys, Dark Fate and Dark Faith. Should these all go under Terminator (Movies)?
• The Revenger's Tragedy - do you mean the play or the movie?
• TOLKIEN J. R. R. - Works & Related Fandoms - This is too broad, please pick a narrower fandom.
• Twilight Series - AMT - please choose an adaptation.
• The Witcher - AMT - we think you mean the video game? Please nominate into Wiedźmin | The Witcher (Video Game), if so.

Also please let us know if there are any duplicates, wandering tags, missing tags and the like!

Finally, we remind you to please remember to put the fandom inside brackets (square brackets or parentheses, either or) for each relationship tag. It makes it much easier for us if you do that and we can approve things faster.

Comments

Duplicates!

[count_nickula]

The Terror

Captain Francis Crozier/Thomas Jopson (Terror)
Francis Crozier/Thomas Jopson (The Terror (TV 2018))

Re: Duplicates!

[thecatmod]

This should be fixed now!

[melody_jade]

1) Two tags have wandered from X-Men (Original Timeline Movies) to (a) X-Men (Alternate Timeline Movies) and (b) Wolverine (Movies).

Jean Grey/Logan/Scott Summers (X-Men OTM)
Logan/Scott Summers (X-Men OTM)

2) 琅琊榜 | Nirvana in Fire (TV) has some duplicate tags.

Lìn Chén/Xiāo Jǐngyǎn (Nirvana in Fire)
Lin Chen/Jingyan (NiF)

Lin Shu | Mei Changsu | Su Zhe/Mu Nihuang (Nirvana in Fire)
Lin Shu | Mei Changsu/Mu Nihuang (Nirvana in Fire)

The top tag is the more canonical one in both cases.

Duplicates

[clawdine]

人渣反派自救系统 - 墨香铜臭 | The Scum Villain's Self-Saving System - Mòxiāng Tóngxiù

Original Shěn Qīngqiū/Yuè Qīngyuán (Scum Villain)
Shen Jiu | Original Shen Qingqiu/Yue Qingyuan

Re: Duplicates

[clawdine]

tag: Shen Wei/Ye Zun/Zhao Yunlan（镇魂 | Guardian - priest)
^ This tag doesn't belong in this branch (novel). Ye Zun is a character from the TV series. 镇魂 | Guardian (TV)

[klutzygirl]

There's a duplicate in Buffyverse

Connor (AtS)/Dawn Summers (Buffyverse)

Connor/Dawn Summers (Buffyverse)

Duplicate!

[sadlikeknives]

Hidden Legacy Series - Ilona Andrews

Augustine Montgomery/Cornelius Harrison (Hidden Legacy Series - Ilona Andrews)
Cornelius Harrison/Augustine Montgomery (Hidden Legacy)

Wandering Snow White/Prince

[sirvalkyrie]

Prince/Snow White (Disney) is showing up under Descendants. While Snow White is in Descendants, her prince isn't.

[(Anonymous)]

In the video game section: “Final Fantasy VIII”

Cloud/Leon (Kingdom Hearts)

Tag wandering

~Kameiko

Thanks! :D

[thecatmod]

These changes should all be made now!

[thecatmod]

Should be updated now!

Re: Duplicate!

[thecatmod]

This should be fixed now!

Re: Wandering Snow White/Prince

[thecatmod]

Should be reassociated now!

[thecatmod]

Should be reassociated now!

Re: Duplicates

[thecatmod]

Should be updated now!

[melody_jade]

I see the changes made for Nirvana in Fire (thanks!) but I'm still seeing wandering tags for X-Men.

Jean Grey/Logan/Scott Summers (X-Men OTM)
Logan/Scott Summers (X-Men OTM)

The above two tags have wandered from X-Men (Original Timeline Movies) to two other fandoms: (a) X-Men (Alternate Timeline Movies) and (b) Wolverine (Movies).

[innie_darling]

Hello! I saw that my nominations were all accepted (thanks!) but one relationship got swapped out. Under Sanditon (TV), I had "Charlotte Heywood & Mary Parker" but that's been replaced by "Gloria Paulton/A. J. Raffles (Sandition)" - could you restore my nommed relationship, please?

[streussal]

Duplicate in Doom Patrol (TV):

Cliff Steele & Crazy Jane (Doom Patrol)
Crazy Jane & Cliff Steele (Doom Patrol)

[seerofrage]

Some duplicates and typos and things:

Free!
Matsuoka Gou/Mikoshiba Isuzu (Free!)
Matsuoka Gou/Mikoshiba Isuzu (Free)

Naruto
Hatake Kakashi/Maito Gai (Naruto)
Hatake Kakashi/Maito Gai | Might Guy (Naruto)

Pocket Monsters | Pokemon (Main Video Game Series)
Dande | Leon/Kibana | Raihan (Pokemon Main Video Game Series)
Leon/Raihan

Dande | Leon/Yuuri | Gloria (Pokemon MVGS)
Yuuri | Gloria/Leon (Pokemon MVGS)

Gloria/Mary | Marnie (Pokemon MVGS)
Mary | Marnie/Yuuri | Gloria (Pokemon (MVGS))
Yuuri | Gloria/Mary | Marnie (Pokemon Main Video Game Series)

Also, with "Kibana | Raihana/Nezu | Piers/Yuuri | Gloria (Pokemon MVGS)" I believe that should be 'Raihan' instead of "Raihana"

There also seems to be a single character tag in there too: Yuuri | Gloria (Sword & Shield Video Game)

Dangan Ronpa (Hope's Peak Arc)
And then with "Mioda Ibuki & Kazuichi Souda (Dangan Ronpa (HPA))" and "Mioda Ibuki & Kazuichi Souda/Tanaka Gundam (Dangan Ronpa (HPA))" it should be 'Souda Kazuichi' instead of "Kazuichi Souda"

Wrong fandom

[jaclynhyde]

Thirteenth Doctor & River Song (FFV) should be in Doctor Who.

[fencesit]

Dupes in Naruto

Hatake Kakashi/Maito Gai (Naruto)
Hatake Kakashi/Maito Gai | Might Guy (Naruto)

I like it without piping because I hate piping, but the piped version is the canonical and opinion on how to spell the character's name is split, so in this case it might make sense to keep the piped tag?

[fencesit]

In Avatar: the Last Airbender I think these relationship don't belong:

Jianzhu & Kelsang & Kuruk & Hei Ran (TRoK)
Kyoshi & Flying Opera Company (TRoK)
Kyoshi/Rangi (TRoK)

TROK stands for "The Rise of Kyoshi" which is a novel series. I can't find it in the tagset, but IMO it's a different fandom the way The Legend of Korra is a different fandom?

[fencesit]

In The Witcher (TV)

Calanthe Fiona Riannon/Eist Tuirseach (The Witcher (TV))
Eist/Calanthe (The Witcher (TV))

Cirilla Fiona Elen Riannon & Geralt z Rivii | Geralt of Rivia (The Witcher (TV))
Geralt of Rivia & Cirilla (The Witcher (TV))

[runicmagitek]

Not the nominator, but wanted to provide some insight regarding the Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon/Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon (Anime and Manga) nominations.

Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon is a live-action TV series from 2003. I've never seen it, but I know that it is loosely based on the anime and manga. It is considered its own continuity.

The anime and manga are technically called Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon, which when translated into English can be Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon, but it is known officially as the prior title. There are two anime series: the 1992 run and the 2014 run (better known as Sailor Moon Crystal). While the 1992 anime doesn't 100% align with the events in the manga, they are similar enough that I've seen them treated as one fandom in other exchanges. Crystal sticks pretty close to the manga continuity, as well, and thus is usually grouped together with the rest.

tl;dr - Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon should be its own category while Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon (Anime and Manga) should be renamed Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon. But I also defer to whatever the nominator(s) intended (they might have mixed them up for all I know).

Hope that helps!

[ashling]

Minerva McGonagall/Female M (James Bond)

Is a crossover that has wandered to James Bond (Craig movies)
You may also want to clarify whether it’s Minerva McGonagall from the movies or books