Tagset Queries - Post 3

[chocolateboxmod]

Back again for yet another set of queries and requests! This will likely be our last one before nominations close, so please help us finalize the tagset!

• Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon/Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon (Anime and Manga) - we think this is the same thing. Can you please confirm if it is, so we can merge them together?
• Chronicles of Narnia - AMT - please choose a version.
• Fullmetal Alchemist - AMT - please choose a version
• Persona Series - please nominate into individual Persona titles or into Persona 3.
• Star Wars - AMT - please choose a more narrow fandom.
• Terminator movies - we have nominations for Terminator (Movies), Terminator Genisys, Dark Fate and Dark Faith. Should these all go under Terminator (Movies)?
• The Revenger's Tragedy - do you mean the play or the movie?
• TOLKIEN J. R. R. - Works & Related Fandoms - This is too broad, please pick a narrower fandom.
• Twilight Series - AMT - please choose an adaptation.
• The Witcher - AMT - we think you mean the video game? Please nominate into Wiedźmin | The Witcher (Video Game), if so.

Also please let us know if there are any duplicates, wandering tags, missing tags and the like!

Finally, we remind you to please remember to put the fandom inside brackets (square brackets or parentheses, either or) for each relationship tag. It makes it much easier for us if you do that and we can approve things faster.

Comments

[silverwill]

Not the nominator either, but two of the nominations for PGSM stick out a bit:

Kino Makoto/Tomoko Takase (Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon)
Tenoh Haruka/Tsukino Usagi (Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon)

Tomoko and Haruka do not appear in the live action PGSM, so these two at least were probably intended for the anime/manga version

X-Men OTM movie ships vacationing in Marvel Comics

[sheliak]

Jean Grey/Logan/Scott Summers (X-Men OTM)
Logan/Scott Summers (X-Men OTM)

Duplicates

[yuuago]

Found duplicates in Frozen (Disney Movies):

Anna/Kristoff (Frozen)
Anna/Kristoff (Frozen 2)

Cheers. :)

[reeby10]

Dupe for Buzzfeed Unsolved (Web Series)

Ryan Bergara/Shane Madej (Buzzfeed Unsolved)
Ryan Bergara/Shane Medej (Buzzfeed Unsolved (Web Series))

[rubylily]

Spotted a misplaced tag: under Final Fantasy V are Thirteenth Doctor & River Song (FFV), but no characters by those names appear in Final Fantasy V.

[sirvalkyrie]

While fandom uses "Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon" to refer to the live action show, AO3 uses it as the all media types.

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed now! (Hopefully)

Re: X-Men OTM movie ships vacationing in Marvel Comics

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be fixed up now!

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now.

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be fixed up now.

In future, may we ask you to provide the text of the correct tag as well if there's a typographical error to be fixed? We don't edit the tags, we have to outright delete them and substitute them with another and it's easier if we can copy the text straight into the console. Thanks!

Re: Wrong fandom

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now.

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now.

[chocolateboxmod]

We've fixed this one up now.

[chocolateboxmod]

Those should be fixed up now!

Re: Duplicates

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now.

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now.

[chocolateboxmod]

That should be fixed up now.

[ashling]

great, thanks!

[innie_darling]

It's not showing up differently on my Nominations page, but if it's fixed elsewhere, that's great - thanks!

Duplicate tags in Game of Thrones and Tangled, and question about ambiguous tag

[melody_jade]

Game of Thrones (TV) has two sets of duplicate tags:

Jaime Lannister & Arya Stark (Game of Thrones TV)
Jaime Lannister & Arya Stark (GoT)

Jaime Lannister/Ned Stark (Game of Thrones)
Jaime Lannister/Ned Stark (GoT)

Tangled (2010) has one set of duplicate tag:

Eugene Fitzherbert | Flynn Rider/Rapunzel (Tangled (2010))
Eugene Fitzherbert | Flynn Rider/Rapunzel (Tangled 2010)

Also from Tangled (2010), Rapunzel Maximus (Tangled) is missing either a & or a /.

[seerofrage]

Thank you, and sorry! I'll remember that for next time C':

[fencesit]

Thank you for all your hard work! I found some tags in Naruto that I think don't belong? I am not the nominator (obviously) and at first I thought they wandered but it looks like they were deliberately nominated under Naruto.

Kawaki & Uzumaki Boruto (Naruto)
Mitsuki & Uzumaki Boruto (Naruto)

I don't want to ruin anyone's sign up plans but... these relationships are from Boruto: Naruto Next Generations, not Naruto, and usually the two fandoms are nominated separately because A) the main characters of each are substantially different and B) many people who are into Naruto aren't into Boruto. Uzumaki Boruto only appears in chapter 700 of the manga (which is an epilogue set a good long while after the rest of the series) and Kawaki and Mitsuki iirc only appear in Boruto: Naruto Next Generations.

I always DNW Boruto stuff just to be safe on my requests, but I strongly feel that they're different fandoms for the purposes of exchanges because, uh, if I'm expected to incorporate Boruto stuff then I'll have a really hard time offering Naruto with any confidence.

Wandering tag?

[(Anonymous)]

I found the following tags in The Hobbit - Tolkien:
Legolas Greenleaf & Thranduil (The Hobbit - Tolkien)
Legolas Greenleaf/Thranduil (The Hobbit - Tolkien)
However, I am 99.5% sure that Legolas does not appear at all in The Hobbit novel, although he does appear in the Jackson movies. While his existence at that point can be inferred from The Lord of the Rings, he still isn't there.
I'm not entirely sure if this is a mistaken nomination or a wandering tag, and if this has been discussed already I apologize but I thought you should know.

-Elsin on ao3

[naryrising]

Minor issue in Castlevania (Cartoon):

Alucard | Adrian Tepes /Hector (Castlevania (Cartoon)) - Alucard has lost one of his names (AO3 usually has him as Alucard | Adrian Tepes | Arikado Genya) but acquired a space before the slash.

Duplicates

[eller]

In "The Bone Key - Sarah Monette", some of the relationships seem to be duplicates, just some of them (Bone Key) and some of them (The Bone Key) but same characters.